The CUSP
Why is Polygamy Illegal?
June 18th, 2010 | 
vIQleSI probably have to start out by stating that I do not endorse (or disapprove of) any sort of -gamy.
My political views are N/A - I'm not a liberace or a conservacrat. I don't know whether I'm left or right (or off in some other non-euclidian dimension altogether)
I was reading a book this morning (this book) and the author was talking about the rights of Americans to practise whatever religion they feel like - as long as they don’t violate the laws of the land. Specifically mentioned were “human sacrifice, animal cruelty and polygamy”.
Now this isn’t the first time that I’ve considered this question, but the surprising juxtaposition of polygamy with violent and unambiguously despicable crimes made me want to write a blog post about it.
So it turns out that there are a lot of emotional rants about polygamy on the internet, which seems to suggest that I need to define what I'm talking about.
Hopefully it should be obvious to my regular readers that I'm not talking about supporting Islamic laws (or any similar society) - where polygamy means women (and young girls) are brought and sold into what is effectively a harem.
Obviously this sort of treatment of anyone (not just women and children) is not acceptable and probably needs to be explicitly prohibited by law.
But is a blanket prohibition on 'polygamy' the correct response?
Let's consider a hypothetical situation:
Two men and 3 women live in a house together. They all have sex with each other (in various configurations and on a regular basis). They're all there by choice and they're all blissfully happy (as much as anyone can be).
Is this illegal?
Should it be?
I can't for the life of me find any reason to prohibit these people from pursuing a lifestyle that makes them happy and fulfils all of their various needs.
Other than Victorian-era, religious prudishness of course.
But, suppose that they want to formalise the relationship and get married - now it’s a different story. Let’s say that each of them gets married 4 times - now what they’re doing is illegal.
Why can’t they all get married (or civil unioned)?
Now there may be some legitimate concerns - for example: IRD and various other government (and other) databases would need some redesigning.
That’s a bit of a cop out though isn’t it? And not really a good enough reason to deny people the right to live in the way that makes them the happiest.
I don’t want to over-simplify what may be a very complicated topic, but it seems to me that there must be a solution that allows for basic human rights all round…
I really appreciate the research you put into it...
TPE Yoga Mat
Fitness Tube
Pilates Ball
Circuit Training
Hello to all, it's actually a pleasant for me to visit this website, it consists of precious Information.raspberry ketones | gynexin | tinnitus miracle
Informative article, exactly what I was looking for.raspberry ketones | gynexin | tinnitus miracle
The Roger rolex replica dubuis made a lot of offers customers to be cautious in selecting and purchasing the product replica, for the reason that many present replica rolex replica products with the terrible quality with elevated cost to the harm of customers. Correctness and information of hermes handbags best class Roger Dubuis Replica Watches can be a conduct for you in receiving a Roger Dubuis watches with excellence and flawless plan.
Chinese firms seized on louis vuitton purse outlet the nationalist spirit to promote their brands. The louis vuitton purses search engine Baidu added a cartoon of the disputed islands (topped with a Chinese flag, of course) to its home page. A grocery store in the southern province of Guangdong set up a coach handbags outlet large display of toothpaste — brand name "China" http://www.cheapcoachsbagusa.net — coach outlet in the shape of a cannon, adorned with a discount coach handbags red banner declaring, "The Diaoyu Islands Are China's!" Meanwhile, louis vuitton outlet online several prominent coach outlet Chinese newspapers with ties to the government carried opinion pieces suggesting the coach outlet online country should slap sanctions on Japan, starting a trade war.
Hi there, I really want to mention, you're wrong. Your post really doesn't make sense at all.worldwide
brands | Fibroids | Natural Clear
Vision
Obviously cheap coach handbags you are kluwless. The coach outlet homosexual “marriage” issue is not coach factory online even close louis vuitton bags to allowing coach outlet people to marry whom they want. coach outlet canada Even if it became law, coach handbags outlet there coach factory online are coach factory outlet online still coach outlet store online many, many coach outlet online restrictions on who can marry whom.
This Authentic Louis Vuitton Handbags is simply the most elegant way to organize your makeup and everyday essentials.Featuring D-rings at both ends, Coach Factory can attach to interior D-ring of your favorite Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet with pochette chain (or strap) OR attach strap/chain to both ends and use as an evening pochette handbag Coach Factory outlet. Make a statement with this spectacular classic piece.
This is 100% Authentic Prada bags GM in monogram canvas.Cowhide leather piping and handles Coach Outlet.Discontinued item with unique shape. Easy access secured with double zipper and spacious interior for all your goods Prada Handbags.Inside is one open pocket. Great companion wherever you go Coach Outlet Online.welcome to shopping,Coach offers Coach Outlet Sale with an elegant but easy luxury. Coach Outlet Online at our website for Coach ,signature designer fashion.
Welcome to Cheap ugg boots for uk outlet online store. We have ugg boots sale at lowest price for men and women. Love ugg boots uk, you must action now!
I always visit new blog everyday and i found your blog pretty cool with useful and very informative posts. Thanks! Frozen Counters | Commercial Fridge Freezer
I can see that this guy is a fruit-loop, and that his 'science' is non-existent. He's out to make money by pushing a load of propaganda.
Having said that, I am participating in a six-week trial of the Paleolithic Diet with before/after blood test and support of my Doctor. The Diet cuts out grains and dairy.
I've never noticed any overt problems with grains, or dairy in my diet, and ate both plentifully 'til now.
So far, a week in, I'm finding that the massive increase in veggies (because I need to eat way more to make up for the lack of easy carbs in grains) appears to be having a pretty positive effect on my general wellbeing. The thing is, I suspect that I'd probably feel the same I just upped my fruit & veg to this level anyway.
how to get a flat stomach for girls exercise at home/
how to get a flat stomach for girls exercise at home/
how to get a flat stomach for girls exercise at home
http://www.howtogetaflatstomachforgirls.com/secrets-to-lose-weight-fast/secrets-to-lose-weight-fast/">how to get a flat stomach for girls exercise at home/
how to get a flat stomach for girls exercise at home/
People on this regime, may in fact expereince significant benefits, but the driver for those benefits may have little to do with the things that are taken out, rather it's because of what's been added. i.e. The whole 'bad grain', 'bad dairy' stuff may be spurious.
http://www.howtogetaflatstomachforgirls.com/flat-stomach-for-girls/how-to-get-a-flat-stomach-for-girls-in-2-weeks//
http://www.howtogetaflatstomachforgirls.com/exercise-to-slim-legs/exercise-to-slim-legs/a>
http://www.howtogetaflatstomachforgirls.com/stomach-for-girls-in-a-week/how-to-get-a-flat-stomach-for-girls-in-a-week-for-teenagers/
http://www.howtogetaflatstomachforgirls.com/secrets-to-lose-weight-fast/secrets-to-lose-weight-fast/">http://www.howtogetaflatstomachforgirls.com/secrets-to-lose-weight-fast/secrets-to-lose-weight-fast/
http://www.howtogetaflatstomachforgirls.com/abs/how-to-have-defined-abs/
http://www.fatburningfoodsformen1.com/belly-fat-exercises-for-men.htm/
http://www.fatburningfoodsformen1.com/abs-exercises-for-men.htm
http://www.fatburningfoodsformen1.com/green-tea-burn-belly-fat.htm/
http://www.fatburningfoodsformen1.com/belly-fat-exercises-for-men.htm/
http://www.fatburningfoodsformen1.com/the-man-diet-free-download.htm
www.theecommercewebhosting.com Thank you discussing this original article! That's worth it to see I adore studying and i am often in search of informative information similar to this.
Cheap Jerseys Online
Wholesale NHL Jerseys
Cheap NBA Jerseys
Wholesale MLB Jerseys
Nike NFL Jerseys Outlet
Cheap New England Patriots Jerseys
Cheap Minnesota Vikings Jerseys
NFL Jerseys For Sale
New Nike Jerseys
Cheap Jerseys For Sale
Elite NFL Jerseys
MLB Jerseys Wholesale
Cheap New Orleans Saints Jerseys
A NFL Elite Jerseys team named Denver Broncos in 1986 had a unique dress code i.e. Minnesota Vikings Jerseys orange crush uniformsthat were made of bright orange and blue color schemes. New Nike Jerseys These uniforms were worn byprofessional players through numerous championship tournaments. Finally in 1996, this NFL teamaltered some changes to the MLB Jerseys Wholesale color of their uniforms by designing their uniforms having averagechoice of colors. Hence their NFL jerseys were made up of dark blue and plain orange Nike NFL Jerseys Outlet accents.Thus Denver Broncos gained popularity and endorsement from all the football fans worldwidewhen they won two Super Bowls nonstop. In the football Cheap Jerseys For Sale stadium on special occasions you willalso hear the whisper and see fans gossiping about old number 7 on the field when Broncos aredressed NFL Jerseys China in their classy orange football jerseys. The Cleveland Browns began their first professional football career in 1946 by wearing white.
I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am launching a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me.. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business
how to get a flat stomach for girls exercise at home
how to get a flat stomach for girls exercise at homefat burning foods for men exercises
pameungpeuk garut selatan
how to get abs for girls exercises/
hey buddy, this is a very interesting article,Read it, liked it, thanks for it . I am looking for a competent writer, long time in this area. Excellent article!
Woah! I'm really enjoying the template/theme of this site. It's simple,
I think you raised and an interesting perspective. Polygamy is a controversial subject, as you can see just from the comments received on this post. Call me prudish, but it's definitely not a good choice for me, and I think there are lots of problems it will bring. But I do agree that when consenting adults come together and agree on something, who are we to judge? I guess reading your post does make me reflect further, but I am still of the opinion that it's something that will bring a lot of trouble and heart-aches. - George with www.buyherepayhere-carlots.com
This is a great blog posting and very useful.
Buy Wrist Weights
Buy Yoga Belt
Buy Yoga Block
I’m wondering how I might be notified when a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your feed which must do the trick! Have a great day! Custom Dissertation writing services | custom essay writing | Coursework Writing Service | Buy Essays | university essay writing tips | cheap custom essays papers | writing service uk | order essay online
I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoyed every little bit of it. I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff on your post. discounthandbagsguide
baby item I have been researching all over google and could not really find a good content for this.
You can call me a little to liberal, but I was living under the impression that nowadays men and women should be regarded as equals. Now, explain to me how can you consider gender equality in a household with one husband and multiple wives, or vice versa? From what I read , polygamy appeared mostly as an instrument to secure an heir. Even in the animal kingdom, polygamy exists to ensure offsprings.
Sure, it's a nice thought to have a harem of spouses to indulge your sexual desires, but if you ever been in love, you know that polygamy can't work.
Pradaxa lawsuit
I enjoyed reading your post and found it to be useful and to the point. Thank you for not rambling on and on just to fill the page.
Acupuncture In Bellevue
I think the point applies about consenting adults and all of that, but there could be some real issues that need to be sorted out. There's bigamy, when one person marries other people, but that often involves deception where the other partners are not aware that there was a previous marriage. There would be legal issues there same as marriage regarding issues like relationship property and children. From what I've seen if someone wants out, it can be extremely difficult even with two partners to sort everything out. Not everyone can be bothered with marriage or civil unions either, I've met lots that just think it's just a piece of paper (with complications attached) and why bother.
Then there is polygamy (multiple mating to use the technical term) Polygyny (man with more than one woman), polyandry (woman with more than one man) and group marriage (more like what you are talking about). Polyandry is pretty darned rare, and I'd say one social issue is that in societies that practice polygamy, it's more to the benefit of men and is a means of control over women as you say. The difficulty would be ensuring that all have the same rights regardless of gender, there would have to be safeguards in place to protect the rights of women as it's not in every case that a woman would have a free and full choice depending on the society.
There is also the issue of gender imbalance, more often seen in societies where boys are preferred but with sex ratios pretty much 50:50 someone's got to miss out on getting in with group marriages. I believe Mormons that practice polygamy, what they do is ship out excess boys when they reach puberty, but that's not really going to cut it if it was a widespread system in common practice.
I suppose what I'm getting at is that it's quite simple having a system of serial monogamy, but once you add in the messiness of human relationships and legal systems it just seems very hard when people can do this as they wish without being fettered by all the issues.
www.shoponlinefashion.co.uk I have been searching for information on this topic for awhile now. So, really appreciate you taking the time to write about it.
What about the third man? For every happy quintuplet bouncing all over each other, there must be a spare man somewhere eating ramen noodles and watching TV alone. He's probably more than a little pissed off about the situation, and a society where 17% of the population is alienated and angry is going to be in trouble. Polygamy can't really work unless there is some way of getting rid of the spares.
You're assuming the third will be male.
You're assuming that this sort of relationship is about sex.
You're assuming "he's" probably pissed off when someone that couldn't live in a relationship like this would not be likely to enter into one to start with.
You're assuming a lot on something you obviously have no experience of.
Relationships like this can, and do, work quite well.
I’m referring to the example as set out in the blog post. With a population ration of approx 50:50, a group of two men and three women leaves one man spare.
I’m assuming he’s pissed off because a polygamous society (one where polygamy is the norm, not just an exception for those who choose it) would leave him alienated. And that’s not about sex, that’s about being part of a family, and a community. I’m thinking primarily of the situation in Colorado City, where the polygamous fundamentalist Mormon community ex-communicates the majority of teenage boys and expels them from the city. This is their solution to the problem of spares, and I don’t think a polygamous society could survive without something similar.
The example gives the five-some as a happy grouping and I don’t see any reason why they wouldn’t be. I describe them as happy in my comment. I suppose if you had read that you might have missed the opportunity to coyly infer that you speak with the authority of a man who has known multi-partnered satisfaction that a ‘straights’ like me can’t begin to imagine. I’m terribly impressed. Obviously.
The 'third man' need not be a problem. I guess it would be a problem in the Mormon community because there are multiple women to one man. But I don't think vIQleS was suggesting that all couples should be two men and three women. As long as the average relationship ratio is like a 50:50 split how it actually divides up is less important thus avoiding your 'spares' problem. I also don't see why bigamy would necessarily mean alienation in a polygamous society.
It would be really nice to think that everybody would end up in a relationship that suits them. But I think there are people whose current relationship is surviving because their partner doesn't have the support to walk away from it. Bullies, emotionally manipulative people, people who are physically abusive, controlling and jealous people. I think in an equitable polygamous society of the sort that's being discussed here people would be a lot less willing to put up with that sort of behaviour. It would be a lot harder to abuse someone in a relationship if there were other people there supporting them. I think some people would be out in the cold and their alienation would need to be addressed.
You're going to use the argument that those who are
would end up
as an argument against a polygamous society? really? Just... wow.
I'm not using it as an argument against polygamous society. I'm raising it as an issue that needs to be addressed. These people are already inflicting a lot of pain on the community and having them alienated isn't going to make that any better.
You are saying 'situation A' would lead to 'problematic situation B'. That to me constitutes an argument against. I also don't think it needs to be addressed. The choice between their possible alienation, should they chose to not change their behaviour as you seem to assume, vs the pain they are inflicting on the people they are close to is not a hard one to make.
Right. See, I wasn’t aware you weren’t capable of understanding a nuanced argument. Pointing out that an idea might have a downside isn’t always an argument against it. It’s quite common for proponents of an idea to explore all of its negative ramifications and possible mitigations and to then weigh them up against the positives when they make their arguments. Pretending that there aren’t any negative side effects to a situation is naïve. That way opponents of the idea can't accuse you of holding hands and dancing around the rainbow and not being prepared when the negative effects rear their ugly heads.
My concern is not that the current perpetrators of domestic abuse won’t be getting enough hugs in a polygamous society. I am not concerned about the effect their alienation would have on those outside the polygamous groups, I am concerned about the effect it would have on everybody else. I consider a group of angry violent people who are isolated from social norms (even if it’s completely their own fault) to be dangerous. I think that in a situation where a person can have multiple partners rejection would be a lot harder to bear (it’s not a matter of an object or desire simply prefer somebody else, they are now specifically rejecting unsuccessful suitors on their own lack of merits), and I think that would lead to an increase in stalker-type obsessive crime we have now, expect that instead of just targeting one person it would be targeted against the relationship group. I don’t think that means people shouldn’t pursue polygamous relationships any more than the current rate of domestic abuse means people should avoid relationships now, just that the discussion around a polygamous society needs to consider more than just the people in polygamous relationships.
Right... so there are arguments for it and arguments against it, what's your point? You seem to be accusing me of a cognitive bias I can't remember the name of which involves 'A leads to B, B is bad, and thus A is bad', however, I'm not making any claims as to B being the only outcome of A or that it is the sole argument for or against A. Saying 'situation A->probelematic situation B constitutes an argument against A' doesn't mean it's the only argument for or against A---hence the use of the indefinite article 'an'---just that it's one of possibly many. Is this really that hard to understand?
Hence these things called 'laws' and 'police' exist.
Firstly, you seem to be assuming that in a society that allowed polygamous relationships polygamy would necessarily become the social norm. Secondly I still don't see the problem. In the case of a bigamous relationship you have one person who ends up putting up with the douche bag and in general has no support, in the other you have someone who is cut out of this particular relationship and should they turn to stalking, or whatever else you want to claim, the original group has support, and there are laws against stalking, etc. that can be levied.
Yet presently, officially, people aren't able to do the former, which was the question of the OP if you look back.
polygamy? Of course I am really against of it and that is why I hate those people who still can't afford to have one wife. But actually i also understand them that what if they really have feelings for the other women. don't know.. Trinket Boxes
This topic is something that I have been looking into for a while now and your insight is exceptional. Thanks for sharing this information. ...customized essays